When a customer’s car is damaged while your shop has it, the claim usually goes to your garagekeepers coverage, and almost never to your general liability. General liability policies typically exclude property in your care, custody or control, and a car whose keys are hanging on your board is exactly that, so what garagekeepers pays then comes down to two questions: whether the cause is covered, and whether you bought legal liability or direct coverage.
The scenarios below are the common ways a customer’s car gets hurt, from a car in the bay or off the lift to theft, hail, a road test and a repair that fails after pickup. For the full set of policies a shop usually carries, see insurance for auto shops.
Key takeaways
- Garagekeepers covers customers’ vehicles while they’re in your care, and general liability usually excludes them.
- Legal liability garagekeepers pays only when your shop is legally responsible for the damage, while direct coverage pays whether or not you were at fault.
- Hail, a storm or a break-in you couldn’t have prevented usually isn’t your fault, which is where the two kinds of garagekeepers give very different answers.
- The cost of redoing a faulty repair is typically not covered by any of your policies, though damage the faulty work causes may be.
- Your lifts and tools, your employees and your customers are each covered by a different policy from the one that covers their cars.
The choice that decides most of these claims
Before any scenario makes sense, you need one distinction straight, because nearly everything below turns on it.
Legal liability coverage pays when your shop is legally liable for the damage: your tech backed the car into a post, someone left a car unlocked overnight with the keys on the seat, or a lift arm wasn’t set properly. If you weren’t negligent, it doesn’t pay, and the customer is left to go through their own auto insurance and their own deductible.
Direct coverage pays for covered damage to a customer’s car regardless of fault. It usually costs more, but it lets you tell a customer “we’ll take care of it” after a hailstorm, instead of sending them home to call their insurer about damage that happened on your lot while you were holding their keys. It comes in two versions, though. Direct primary pays first, regardless of fault, while direct excess also ignores fault but pays only what the customer’s own auto policy doesn’t, so after hail the customer’s insurer may still be the first stop; ask which one you’re being quoted.
Read that example again with your own lot in mind. Legal liability is the cheaper form and, on paper, the logical one, since it pays exactly when you did something wrong. But the claim that’s hardest to explain at the counter is the one where nobody did anything wrong: weather, a thief who cut the fence, a fire that started two units down. Those are the cases where legal liability tends to say no, and where the customer standing at your counter doesn’t much care whose fault it was. If you hold cars overnight, outdoors, in a place where hail or break-ins happen, our view is that direct coverage is usually worth pricing, even if you end up choosing the other.
Either way, a deductible applies, and with garagekeepers it’s often per car, sometimes with a cap per event, so a storm that damages eight cars can mean eight deductibles. How to choose a deductible explains how that trade-off works.
Eight things that happen to customers’ cars
1. Your tech backs a car into a post
You’re at fault, so both legal liability and direct garagekeepers typically respond, minus the deductible. It’s the simplest claim a shop can have.
2. A car comes off the lift
The customer’s car is a garagekeepers claim, but the lift isn’t. Damage to the lift itself falls to whichever policy covers your equipment, often tools and equipment insurance, or commercial property for a lift bolted into the building, and either typically covers accidental damage while excluding wear and mechanical breakdown, so ask which applies to yours; if a tech is hurt in the fall, that’s workers’ comp. One accident, three policies.
3. A car is stolen from your lot overnight
With legal liability, the answer depends on whether you were negligent. Keys left in an unlocked car, a gate left open or a broken fence you knew about make you more likely to be liable; a lot that was locked, lit and fenced, with thieves who cut through anyway, may leave you not liable at all, and the claim goes to the customer’s own auto policy, if it covers theft. With direct coverage, theft from your lot is typically covered either way, subject to the policy’s terms.
4. Hail dents six cars waiting for pickup
Weather isn’t anyone’s fault, so legal liability usually won’t pay, though direct coverage typically will, as long as your policy includes causes other than collision.
5. A tech has an accident on a road test
Damage to the customer’s car during a road test is typically covered by garagekeepers when your policy includes collision, so check that it does before your techs road-test anything. Injuries to other drivers, or damage to their cars, are a different question entirely, because general liability typically excludes claims that come from driving a vehicle; liability for driving customers’ cars is usually handled by garage liability or auto coverage, which is separate insurance that Corgi doesn’t offer. If the shop owns its own vehicles, like a tow truck or a loaner, those need commercial auto too, which the NAIC notes typically carries higher liability limits than personal coverage. Garagekeepers vs. garage liability lays out the differences.
6. A repair fails after the customer drives away
Say you replaced a brake line, and a week later it fails and the customer hits a fence. Garagekeepers no longer applies, because the car has left your care, and the cost of redoing your own work is typically excluded. General liability may respond to injuries and to damage to other people’s property caused by your finished work, through its products-completed operations coverage, subject to its terms, but whether damage to the customer’s own car is covered depends on your policy’s wording, so ask an underwriter before you need to know.
7. A laptop disappears from a customer’s car
Personal belongings left in customers’ cars usually aren’t covered by garagekeepers, and if an employee took it, that’s a question for crime or employee dishonesty coverage, which is separate insurance that Corgi doesn’t offer, and some garagekeepers forms also exclude theft of a car by your own employees.
8. A fire in one bay spreads to the cars beside it
A welding fire or an electrical fire that damages several cars at once is where your limit matters most. Garagekeepers limits usually apply per location, so the limit has to cover every car that might be inside on your busiest day, while the building and contents fall under commercial property and your tools under tools and equipment.
The eight, side by side
| What happened | Legal liability garagekeepers | Direct garagekeepers | What else may apply |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tech backs a car into a post | Typically pays | Typically pays | Usually nothing else |
| Car comes off the lift | Typically pays for the car | Typically pays for the car | Tools and equipment or property for the lift, workers’ comp for the tech |
| Car stolen from a locked lot | Only if you were negligent | Typically pays | The customer’s own auto policy |
| Hail on the lot | Usually doesn’t pay | Typically pays | The customer’s own auto policy |
| Road-test accident | Pays for the car if collision is included | Pays for the car if collision is included | Garage liability or auto coverage for other people |
| Repair fails after pickup | Doesn’t apply | Doesn’t apply | General liability, possibly, for the damage the work caused |
| Belongings missing from a car | Usually excluded | Usually excluded | Crime coverage (not offered by Corgi), if an employee took them |
| Fire damages several cars | Typically pays if you’re liable, up to the limit | Typically pays, up to the limit | Property for the building, tools coverage for equipment |
Every answer is subject to the policy’s terms, limits and exclusions, and where the direct column says it pays, direct excess coverage pays only what the customer’s own auto policy doesn’t.
See what garagekeepers costs for your business
About five minutes, all online. Your certificate is ready the day you buy.
When the customer’s insurer calls you
Why would a customer’s own insurance company ever call your shop? Because it wants its money back.
Customers sometimes file with their own auto insurer first, especially after an accident at your shop, and if that insurer pays them for damage you caused, it may then come after your shop to recover what it paid. That’s called subrogation, and it’s the reason legal liability coverage still matters even when the customer has good insurance of their own, since your garagekeepers policy is what answers that demand when it arrives, sometimes months after the car has gone home.
If a customer’s insurer contacts you, don’t agree to pay or admit fault on the phone. Report it to your insurer and let them handle it, and follow the steps in how to file a business insurance claim.
Size the limit for your worst day
It’s tempting to set a garagekeepers limit from an average day. That’s backwards.
Count the most cars you ever hold at once, inside and on the lot, and estimate their combined value on that day, the Friday before a holiday weekend when every bay is full and the lot is stacked with cars waiting on parts. A shop that does fleet work, restorations or late-model European cars may hold far more value than its bay count suggests, and since the limit usually applies per location, a single fire or storm that hits everything at once still has to fit inside it.
Security still matters, because it affects both your risk and your price. Fencing, lighting, cameras, locked key storage and bringing cars inside overnight make theft less likely and can count in your favor when you’re quoted, and garagekeepers insurance shows how the limit and deductible options work.
Frequently asked questions
Doesn’t my customer’s own car insurance cover damage at my shop?
Sometimes, if they carry the right coverage, but they’ll pay their own deductible and may hold it against your shop. If you caused the damage, their insurer may also pursue your shop to recover what it paid, whereas garagekeepers can let your business handle the claim directly, especially with direct primary coverage.
Does garagekeepers cover a car stolen from my lot?
Often, subject to the policy’s terms. With direct coverage, theft from your lot is typically covered regardless of fault, but with legal liability coverage it’s usually covered only if your shop was negligent, such as leaving keys in an unlocked car.
Are a customer’s belongings left in the car covered?
Usually not. Garagekeepers covers the vehicle itself, and personal items inside it are commonly excluded, so ask customers to remove valuables at drop-off and note anything left behind on the work order.
Will a sign that says “not responsible for damage” protect my shop?
Not reliably. Signs and work-order disclaimers may not stop a customer from bringing a claim, and whether they hold up depends on your state’s law and on what happened, so treat them as a supplement to coverage for cars in your care.
