A customer’s car slips off your lift and the door panel is crushed: that’s a garagekeepers claim. The same customer slips on coolant in your waiting room and breaks a wrist: that’s a liability claim, whether your shop carries garage liability or general liability. Garagekeepers insurance covers customers’ vehicles while they’re in your care, in the bay, on the lot overnight or out on a test drive, while garage liability is liability coverage for the business itself, answering claims that your operations hurt someone or damaged property that wasn’t in your care.
The names are nearly identical, and that’s a real problem, because the gap between the two policies is exactly where shops get caught. A liability policy, by either name, usually excludes the very cars you’re paid to work on, though garagekeepers exists to fill that hole.
Key takeaways
- Garagekeepers covers customers’ vehicles while they’re in your shop’s care, custody or control, subject to the policy’s terms.
- Garage liability and general liability cover injuries and damage your operations cause to other people, but usually exclude customers’ cars in your care.
- Garagekeepers comes in two main forms: legal liability, which pays only when your shop is at fault, and direct coverage, which pays regardless of fault.
- If you keep cars overnight, especially outdoors, direct coverage is usually worth the extra cost.
- Neither policy pays to redo your own faulty repair, and your own lifts and tools need property or tools coverage.
The difference in one table
| Garagekeepers | Garage liability or general liability | |
|---|---|---|
| What it protects | Customers’ vehicles in your care | People and property affected by your operations |
| Who is usually claiming | The car’s owner, or their insurer | Customers, visitors, neighbors |
| Example claim | Your tech backs a customer’s car into a post | A customer trips over an air hose in the bay |
| The exclusion that matters most | Faulty work, belongings left in cars | Property in your care, custody or control |
| Fault | Depends on the form you choose | Your shop generally has to be legally responsible |
Garage liability is a form of liability coverage designed for auto businesses, and the main reason it exists is driving: garage forms typically include liability for driving customers’ cars, which general liability excludes, though exactly what’s included depends on the form. Corgi doesn’t sell garage liability. For a repair shop, body shop or detailer, Corgi’s lineup pairs general liability for the operations side with garagekeepers for customers’ cars, and if you go that route, arrange coverage for test drives and road calls separately.
Why won’t your liability policy cover the cars?
Because of one short exclusion. Liability coverage is written to pay for harm to third parties, and it commonly excludes damage to property in your care, custody or control, which means property you’re holding, working on or responsible for at the time it’s damaged.
For most businesses that exclusion barely matters, since a bakery doesn’t hold much of anyone else’s property and a consultant holds almost none. For an auto shop, however, the same short clause removes the most valuable property on the premises, which is a lot full of other people’s cars, and it removes it on purpose, on the reasoning that property in your control is a business risk of its own and is better insured on a policy written for it. Garagekeepers is that policy.
Pick direct coverage if cars sleep on your lot
Garagekeepers usually comes in two main forms, and the choice decides which claims get paid.
- Legal liability pays only when your shop is legally responsible for the damage. If your technician dents a fender, it pays, but if a hailstorm dents every car on the lot and your shop did nothing wrong, it may not.
- Direct coverage pays for covered damage whether or not your shop was at fault, so hail, a fallen tree or a break-in on a secured lot can be covered even when nobody at your shop was careless. Direct coverage can itself be written as excess, where the customer’s own auto policy pays first, or primary, where yours does, so ask which one you’re being quoted.
Legal liability sounds like enough, because most damage in a shop really is somebody’s mistake. But the losses that hurt a small shop most tend to be the ones with nobody to blame: a storm, a fire that starts next door, a thief who cuts the fence. Those are the nights when six or eight cars are damaged at once, and they’re exactly the claims legal liability may refuse.
Think about what happens next under legal liability. Six customers each call their own insurer, some won’t have weather coverage, and those customers will look to the shop that had their car. Legal liability may be technically right to refuse the claim, but it leaves you choosing between paying out of pocket and losing customers. Direct coverage costs more because it pays on more claims, and for a shop that keeps cars overnight, outdoors or for days at a time, that’s money well spent. First-party vs. third-party coverage explains why legal liability behaves like liability insurance, while direct coverage behaves more like property insurance for cars you don’t own.
A quick-turn shop that keeps every car indoors and returns it the same day has a better case for legal liability. Even then, though, run the hail math before you decide.
Six things that can happen in one week
| What happens | Which coverage typically responds |
|---|---|
| A customer slips on coolant in the waiting area | General liability, for their medical bills and any lawsuit |
| A car slips off a lift and its door panel is crushed | Garagekeepers, for the customer’s car |
| The same lift is bent beyond repair | Commercial property, for your lift, subject to its terms |
| Your tech rear-ends another car on a test drive | Garagekeepers with collision for the customer’s car; injuries and damage to the other car are an auto liability question |
| A brake job is done wrong and has to be redone | Usually no coverage for redoing the work itself |
| A mechanic burns an arm on an exhaust manifold | Workers’ comp |
Look twice at the test-drive row. A general liability policy can look as if it covers anything that happens during business hours, but general liability policies generally exclude injury and damage arising from the use of autos; Oregon’s small business insurance guide lists claims related to operating an automobile or truck among the things standard liability doesn’t protect against, and the California Department of Insurance describes commercial auto coverage as protecting a company from liability stemming from automobiles used in the business. Liability for the other driver usually belongs to commercial auto or garage liability coverage written for driving, which Corgi doesn’t sell. If your techs drive customers’ cars on public roads, ask how that liability is covered before the next road test.
Faulty work has a wrinkle too. The cost to redo a bad repair is generally not covered by any of these policies, but if the bad repair later causes a crash that injures someone, that’s a different claim, and how a liability policy responds depends on its terms, including any products-completed operations coverage. Who pays when a customer’s car is damaged at your shop? walks through more of these situations.
How much limit, and which deductible?
Garagekeepers is usually written with a limit for each location and a deductible that applies to each car, and both choices matter more than they look.
- Size the limit to your busiest night. Count the most vehicles you hold at once, including overnight, and what they’re worth. A shop that works on luxury cars or keeps a dozen vehicles inside needs a higher limit than one with three bays and a quick turnaround.
- Check collision. Damage while you move or test-drive a car is typically covered only if your garagekeepers includes collision.
- Think about where cars sit. Fencing, lighting and indoor storage affect both the risk and the price.
The deductible deserves its own thought, because it multiplies. A per-car deductible on a hail loss across eight cars is paid eight times, unless your policy caps the total deductible for one event, so ask whether it does before you pick a higher deductible to save on the price. How to choose a deductible covers the trade-off.
See what garagekeepers costs for your business
About five minutes, all online. Your certificate is ready the day you buy.
What neither policy covers
- Belongings left in cars. Personal items inside customers’ vehicles usually aren’t covered by garagekeepers.
- Your lifts and shop equipment. Equipment at your location, like a bolted-in lift, is generally a commercial property matter.
- Scanners and tools that leave the shop. Gear you take on road calls needs tools and equipment coverage.
- Wear, rust and mechanical failure. A car that breaks down on its own while it’s parked with you hasn’t suffered the kind of damage your coverage was written for.
The care, custody or control exclusion isn’t unique to auto shops, but it rarely costs any other trade as much: it shows up wherever a business holds property that belongs to a customer, and what business insurance doesn’t cover lists it alongside the other common gaps.
Frequently asked questions
Doesn’t general liability cover customers’ cars?
Usually not. General liability policies typically exclude property in your care, custody or control, and a customer’s car in your shop fits that description, so garagekeepers is the policy written to cover those vehicles, subject to its own terms and limits.
Is garagekeepers the same as garage liability?
No. Garage liability covers injuries and damage caused by your shop’s operations, while garagekeepers covers customers’ vehicles while they’re in your care, and most shops need protection for both: one for the people and property around them, one for the cars they’re working on.
Should I choose legal liability or direct coverage?
Legal liability pays only when your shop is at fault, so weather, vandalism and theft without negligence may not be covered. Direct coverage pays regardless of fault but costs more, and shops that keep cars overnight or outdoors usually get the most from it.
Won’t the customer’s own auto insurance pay?
Sometimes, but you can’t count on it. A customer whose own auto policy covers the damage may claim on it, and their insurer may then try to recover the cost from your shop through subrogation if it believes you were at fault, which is why garagekeepers lets you handle the damage without relying on the customer’s coverage. If your direct coverage is written on an excess basis, though, it expects the customer’s policy to pay first, which is one reason to ask for primary.
Do detailers and tire shops need garagekeepers?
If customers leave vehicles in your care, the exposure is the same, however quick the work. A detailer who moves cars, a tire shop with cars on lifts and a body shop holding cars for weeks all have customers’ vehicles in their custody.
